The use of a bandwidth impacts the type of causal estimand we can calculate in a regression discontinuity design analysis. Because the RDD approach uses a subset of the full dataset, we can only estimate the local average treatment effect (LATE). The LATE is the average treatment effect among the subset of data that falls within the range of the bandwidth.
To estimate the LATE in RDD, a regression model that allows for different slopes on each side of the cutpoint is fit. The regression model is then used to get a predicted value of the outcome variable for each treatment group at the cutpoint. The difference between the predicted outcome values of the treatment and control groups is an estimate of the LATE.
We can use the
RDestimate() function from the
rdd package as follows to fit the local linear regression model for the contribution matching data:
cont_rdd <- RDestimate( formula = contribution ~ size, #outcome regression model data = cont_data, #dataset cutpoint = 300, #cutpoint bw = cont_ik_bw #bandwidth )
RDestimate() function fits the local linear regression model at the provided bandwidth, but also at half of the bandwidth and twice the bandwidth. If the estimate of the LATE is relatively the same across bandwidths, we can be more confident that the estimate is accurate. We see all three estimates when we print the results.
Call: RDestimate(formula = contribution ~ size, data = cont_data, cutpoint = 300, bw = cont_ik_bw) Coefficients: LATE Half-BW Double-BW 90.60 110.67 71.62
The model output shows us that the LATE is 90.60, meaning that in this dataset, we can conclude that employer-sponsored retirement contribution matching programs led to an increase in average monthly contributions of $90.60. However, we see that the estimate changes based on the bandwidth, ranging from $110.67 at half of the bandwidth to $71.62 at twice the bandwidth.
air_data dataset has been loaded for you in notebook.Rmd. The IK optimal bandwidth has been saved as
air_ik_bw. Use the
RDestimate() function to fit the local linear regression model using
air_ik_bw as the bandwidth. Save the results to
Print the results of the local linear regression. Take note of the estimates of the LATE at the different bandwidths. Are the estimates different or fairly similar? What do you think this says about the reliability of our estimate?